Hallmark Hunks
In the small town of Fletcher’s Grove, Emily Lane solves Christmas mysteries in the Hallmark series Mistletoe Murders. 
She owns a cozy shop called Under the Mistletoe, where she sells holiday items and solves local mysteries. Based on an audible podcast, Mistletoe Murders is a fun cozy mystery series filled with excitement. Emily partners with Detective-Constable Sam Wilner, and their chemistry adds depth to the story. Each episode is fast-paced with lively dialogue, letting each character shine. I love Emily’s clever voice-overs that share her thoughts and make solving mysteries enjoyable. This is Hallmark’s first Christmas cozy mystery series and it has been a success—packed with festive cheer, cozy mysteries, holiday suspense, and a sweet romance. While solving small cases, Emily also faces her past and uncovers who is watching her and why. Mistletoe Murders is a must-watch for Hallmark Christmas fans who enjoy Christmas cozy mysteries with a slow-burn romance! This post highlights Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders.
This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my disclosure and privacy policy.
Fletcher’s Grove
This small town has a cute, lively Main Street and active residents. Emily Lane runs a Christmas shop called Under the Mistletoe and lives above it with her cats. People often meet at Sue’s Diner.
2024
Emily Lane runs a Christmas shop and helps solve crimes in Fletcher’s Grove. She looks into a case of a poisoned cookie and odd happenings in the town choir. Emily keeps her past hidden while getting closer to Detective Sam Wilner.
2025
This season includes murders and an art theft, leading Emily to go undercover. As Emily Lane and Sam begin to trust one another, their connection grows stronger, ending in a surprising reveal that Emily Lane is actually Grace, a hacker.
In Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders, Emily Lane’s Christmas shop, Under the Mistletoe, is in Fletcher’s Grove. You’ll find festive decorations, ornaments, wrapping paper, and lights that create a joyful atmosphere.
Emily makes each moment special with her colorful gift wrap at the cashier’s desk. The Christmas trees in the shop shine with bright ornaments. Emily tells her staff to keep everything bright like her smile. With a nice view of the snowy streets and fun activities inside, Under the Mistletoe is where Christmas magic happens. It’s no wonder this shop is a favorite during the holidays. Emily’s Under the Mistletoe Christmas Shop in Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is the perfect cozy spot for Fletcher’s Grove locals to find Christmas joy and special gifts!
“A shop that worships at the shrine of Christmas 365 days a year maybe be considered to be far from ordinary.”
In her festive Christmas shop, Emily Lane makes gift wrapping enjoyable. With bright paper, gifts become exciting surprises that capture the holiday spirit. For Emily, wrapping is a joyful task that adds to the Christmas cheer. Each gift from her shop is carefully finished with a pretty bow, reflecting her care. This special touch makes her wrapping services a cherished tradition in the Fletcher's Grove community.
Hallmark's rustic Christmas wrapping paper resembles a Hallmark Christmas movie, featuring the red truck and red barn!
Each sheet of wrapping paper is perfect for a standard shirt box and comes with 16 gift tags, making wrapping simple!
WayFair has excellent Christmas wrapping paper and storage organizers!
Paper Source has great Christmas wrapping paper and unique gift accessories!
This Christmas wrapping paper has two beautiful designs in gold, red, and black for a festive feel.
In Mistletoe Murders, Emily's Christmas shop is filled with colorful ornaments and lovely trees. The soft lights create a cozy feeling, like a warm hug on a cold day. The smell of fresh pine brings back happy holiday memories for Emily Lane!
Super cute Old World glass-blown, hand-painted ornament of Rudolph and Clarice in soft ivory and brown.
The design is inspired by classic Christmas styles in red, green, and white, featuring familiar shapes with neat patterns.
Fill these plastic ornaments with your favorites—ribbons, candy, photos, or miniatures. Let your creativity shine!
Walmart offers a wide variety of genuine Hallmark Christmas ornaments, including Keepsake ornaments.
Etsy has unique handmade Christmas ornaments that are great to give and keep!
Sending and receiving Christmas cards is a beloved holiday custom! Emily’s shop offers beautiful cards that remind us of the cozy mystery series Mistletoe Murders. Visitors can find unique cards filled with warm wishes and holiday cheer. These cards are more than just paper; they are small gifts of love that help connect people during the festive season.
I love this set! 24 fun designs in this pack of unique greetings and matching envelopes in a beautiful box.
This is a great set for anyone because the card is a nice blue with a simple Happy Holidays!
Set of holiday cards with 24 handmade designs featuring Christmas icons in a sweet keepsake box.
Whether whimsical or elegant, LovePop offers a unique selection of Christmas cards that stand out.
Etsy has unique, handmade Christmas cards you won't find anywhere else from talented creators.
Emily's lovely shop in Mistletoe Murders is filled with Christmas spirit and decorations that brighten the season. She carefully cleans her favorite items to please her customers. Her love for the holiday is so strong that even Detective Sam's daughter, Violet, jokes that she’s “really into Christmas!” For Emily, it’s all about creating a warm space that spreads joy. With some effort and the right materials, your decorations can shine (just like Emily's!) and bring happiness, making this Christmas special!
“Christmas is all about the sparkle. Dust is the enemy of sparkle.”✨
Small feather duster crafted from soft ostrich feathers. Its gentle touch allows you to effortlessly reach into those tricky nooks and crannies,
Iowa Pine is a great natural cleaner that smells like a fresh cut tree and works well!
"Maybe Sam was wrong. Maybe some investigations are like Agatha Christie plot… Because the final piece of this puzzle just felt perfectly into place."
Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is a charming Christmas cozy mystery! I love reading cozy Christmas mysteries filled with holiday cheer. These stories have amateur detectives who solve light-hearted puzzles. Unlike regular thrillers, cozy mysteries focus on characters and happy endings instead of violence, offering a comforting escape during the busy holiday season. Following the clues with the characters in cozy Christmas mysteries makes you feel the warmth of community, friendship, and holiday joy. Whether it’s finding a gift or solving a simple puzzle, these stories capture the spirit of the season. Snuggling up with a cozy mystery book warms our hearts and brings back sweet childhood memories. Here are my favorite Christmas cozy mystery books for this season that will entertain you and keep you cozy all through the holidays!
In Rudolph, New York, a town that celebrates Christmas year-round, shop owner Merry Wilkinson investigates holiday-related murders.
The Amish Candy Shop Mysteries combines Amish culture, candy making, and a love story between chocolatier Bailey King and her sheriff fiancé.
At the North Pole, Santa's new wife, April Claus, plans for a perfect holiday while solving a mystery
The first book in this series is Everyone in My Family Has a Secret. It features amateur sleuth Ernest Cunningham.
short stories | A set of twelve holiday crime stories for The Mysterious Bookshop in New York, given as Christmas gifts to customers of America's oldest mystery bookstore.
Holly Wood is saved by Mrs. Claus and now in Candy Cane Hollow, where she and her son, Nick, encounter holiday mysteries.
A newlywed couple must figure out a murder mystery while dealing with their marriage and past issues. 💚Marriage of Convenience
This book is the last in the Fixer-Upper Mysteries series that inspired Hallmark's Fixer-Upper Mysteries.
The Hallmark Mystery series Mistletoe Murders draws inspiration from this cozy mystery podcast on Audible.
This book from the Hannah Swensen Mysteries is a Christmas mystery and Hallmark created a special holiday movie from it!
Emily Lane is starting fresh in Fletcher’s Grove in Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders. She leaves her old life behind to open a Christmas shop in this cheerful town. Her new beginnings bring friendship and unexpected love. As she adjusts, she meets kind locals, each with their own stories and holiday plans, showing her that family can be found anywhere. One of them is a nice man whose smile makes her feel welcome. These heartwarming small-town Christmas romance tales follow Emily’s adventures in Fletcher’s Grove and celebrate what the season is truly about: connection, joy, and new starts. I love that Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is a cozy Christmas mystery series in a charming town that fully embraces Christmas! Here are sweet, wholesome small-town Christmas romance books.
Olive fakes a relationship with her work rival at a Vermont Christmas lodge with her family because of a little lie. 💚Fake Dating, 💚Enemies-to-Lovers, 💚Small Town
In Chestnut Ridge, Sheila decorates a tree for the Christmas fundraiser. Fire captain Tucker rallies volunteers for a family in need. 💚Small Town
Olive is hired by Liam's parents to save the farm from being sold. 💚Friends-to-Lovers, 💚Grumpy/Sunshine, 💚Small Town
Clara gets money from her mother, moves to a small town, and starts a bakery. 💚Dog 💚Small Town
A woman goes back to her hometown to convince her producer to let her be the permanent host of a morning TV show. 💚Second Chance Romance, 💚Small Town
Clementine is staying a cozy cabin when Noah unexpectedly arrives, and they are stuck together in the snow. 💚Second Chance Romance, 💚Best Friend's Brother, 💚Small Town
When high school rivals Georgie and Eoin return to town for Christmas, the new Glenwood Christmas Games pulls them into a competition. 💚High School Rivals, 💚Small Town
Novella | Trapped with the guy who broke her heart, they have to spend a week snowed in at a cozy cabin. 💚Enemies-to-Lovers, 💚Brothers Best Friend
Nia works at a gift shop on a special street. She jokes about meeting her Prince Charming and meets the nice owner who looks like him. 💚Small Town
After losing her job and boyfriend on the same day, she goes back to her hometown to help organize the Yule Tides Festival. 💚Brother's Best Friend, 💚Small Town
Novella | Madison goes back home to her family's struggling Christmas tree farm in Oregon after a fire. 💚Christian Fiction, 💚Small Town
A woman who forgot the joy of Christmas and a man discover the holiday spirit while making his nephew's Christmas special in North Pole, Alaska. 💚Small Town
A hockey player goes back to his hometown for Christmas, where he meets a lively videographer and confronts his past. 💚Small Town
A young mother feels welcome at the Comfort Food Café and meets a friendly newcomer. 💚Small Town
Becca doesn't like Christmas; she goes to the Comfort Food Cafe to spend the holidays with her sister and find love. 💚Small Town
Novella | High school sweethearts reconnect again at Christmas. 💚Small Town, 💚Second-Chance Romance
The Stoker sisters and their family inn in a lovely snowy town about family, love, and new starts.
💚Small Town
Sophia comes back home and quickly reunites with her first love. Over the next year, they keep reconnecting. 💚Second-Chance Romance, 💚Small Town
In Fletcher’s Grove, Sue’s Diner is where Emily meets Detective Peter in a funny way in Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders. They both reach for a cup of coffee, but Peter grabs it first, saying it’s his. Sue makes a fresh pot for Emily. This kicks off their story! The diner isn’t just for eating; it’s a lively place where the community gathers for meals, book clubs, and coffee. Sue, the owner, is cheerful and adds joy and sass to her customers. The aroma of coffee and laughter fills the air, setting up a fun story with unique characters. With its charm and cozy feel, the local diner is the perfect spot where gossip and mysteries happen.
These deli paper sheets are stylish and practical, enhancing the look of plates and food baskets.
I just love this retro diner mug! Made of durable ceramic, it's anything but fragile.
These are classic to-go coffee cups, and I really like their simple style. The kraft paper sleeves keep your hands safe from heat.
I've had this mini espresso machine for years, and it's a great purchase. It's compact, fits in small spaces, and makes tasty espresso!
These are the espresso capsules I use for this machine.
In Mistletoe Murders, Emily Lane is a quiet person with two cats, Doyle and Mosley, who brighten her small apartment above her shop, Under the Mistletoe. Living with her cats brings her small joys. After a long day, Emily loves to snuggle with them and finds comfort in this routine. The gentle purring of Doyle and Mosley creates a calm atmosphere in her home. Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is a cozy mystery series featuring cats, making it a delightful cat mystery series! Here are some cozy cat mystery book suggestions!
“Who is this socially awkward, caffeine-obsessed cat lady?
Sheila runs a Murder Society in Paradise Cove, which has comfy cottages by a quiet beach, a cat, a heron, and a K-9 officer.
Kathleen Paulson, a librarian in Mayville Heights, Minnesota, solves mysteries with her two special cats, Hercules and Owen.
Cora Hearth, a witch who inherits her Aunt Lavender's magic shop, teams up with an immortal cat named Selene🐈⬛ and a charming stranger to solve quirky small-town mysteries.
Reluctant librarian Ann seeks help from her patrons to solve a murder in the cozy town of Whitby and prevent further tragedy.
Ashley Branson is excited to start her dream project—a cat yoga studio. But helping clients relax and finding homes for cats becomes murderous.
Innkeeper Holly Miller and her pets help solve crimes, using their keen senses to find clues.
Conrad, the detective cat, joins Lulu's life after a recent loss. When Lulu's mother-in-law dies under strange circumstances, Conrad helps her investigate.
Charlie Harris rediscovers his love for books and finds himself in a real-life mystery with his old classmate, a famous author. 
Sarah Grayson runs a secondhand shop in North Harbor, Maine, with her cat, Elvis. They work with quirky older detectives to solve murders.🐈⬛
Hallmark’s Mistletoe Murders is enjoyable, and the podcast adds to the fun. This series combines romance and mystery, based on a popular podcast from Audible. Cobie Smulders plays Emily Lane, bringing a festive town to life with decorations and surprises. The show connects with classic holiday themes. The podcast engages listeners with beautiful music and a lively atmosphere. It’s more than just a mystery; it’s a holiday getaway for those who enjoy warmth and a good whodunit. The Audible podcast of Mistletoe Murders takes us to a place filled with holiday cheer and intriguing mysteries.
The Hallmark Mystery series Mistletoe Murders draws inspiration from this cozy mystery podcast on Audible.
Latest Posts
Hallmark Hunks
‘Fall into Love’ Movies
Haunted Harmony Mysteries
Garage Sale Mysteries
Cozy Mystery Books
Halloween Costumes